Have you noticed how, when affluent individuals or corporations want something, they don’t care who gets crushed in the process?
Watching a film on the life of Fernando Valenzuela, former pitcher for the Los Angeles Dodgers, I learned that the land upon which Dodger Stadium was built was acquired by forcefully evicting the residents. In the first half of the twentieth century, Chavez Ravine was a semi-rural Mexican-American community in the suburbs of Los Angeles. By the early 1950’s, it was home to over 1800 Mexican-American families. These families were not offered alternative housing for relocation–they were forced out and left stranded. The owners of Dodger Stadium won…the mostly impoverished Hispanic families who lived there had seemingly no right to protest.
The Panama Canal was built with the slave labor of the men who were promised money and a better lifestyle as they were deceived into digging the canal…an act that established the United States of America as a super power at that time in history. Was the loss of lives & the abusive treatment of laborers justified by the accomplishment of connecting two oceans and making for easier trade routes? Five thousand (5,000) human lives were lost during the construction of the Panama Canal. How does one measure success then?
Corporations are the modern day Goliaths and the little peon people are the Davids who oppose this giant.
We had our recent battle with the Goliath, Crystal Geyser Water Bottling Company…what would make me trust that a corporation, once they have their foot in the door of our community, would care about seventy-five home owners in the immediate area or the three thousand residents of the city of Mount Shasta? How would taking the water from this mountain affect the mountain itself? Why should the citizens allow this corporation to get away without doing an Environmental Impact Report (EIR)? What makes me believe that even in this time of drought, that the voices of affected individuals would be heard? Corporations appear to have immunity from the law. Citizens don’t appear to be protected by the law.
The fact that corporations are considered as a “person” with the same rights as a person has undermined and mocked human rights. The truth is that not by any stretch of the imagination is a corporation a person. Where is the equality when a group of citizens with limited financial resources oppose a corporation with vast financial resources? Not.
Water is a human need…how bizarre that it be taken from the land of origin, bottled, shipped & profited from while the community of origin receives neither guarantees for its own water needs and use nor remunerations.
Are rights only ours to fight for?
If the Crystal Geyser deal was a true collaborative effort, then the community should have been involved from the beginning and not be notified through an after-the-fact newspaper photo of the ribbon cutting for the Crystal Geyser Bottling Plant! Where were our city council fathers when this was being formulated?
While we elect and entrust our city officials to represent the best interests of the community and the environment, it is neither blind nor mute trust. It has to be an educated trust. We, as citizens, do not hand over our power to the elected officials. We educate ourselves and ensure that they are true to our communal values of preserving the pristine quality of this area in order to provide optimally for ourselves and our families and future generations and for the wildlife that thrives here.
Earlier this year, 2021, after seven-and-a-half years of opposition and court battles, Crystal Geyser withdrew their interests in the water bottling plant in Mt. Shasta:
A newspaper article read:
“Fierce and persistent local opposition was at least one factor in the company’s decision to back away from plans to bottle and sell Mt. Shasta’s famously clean water. The announcement came during a Mt. Shasta city council meeting last week.”
I’ve learned that any victory is temporary. The fight for rights, whether it be personal or political, has to be sustained over time.